December 8, 2016

False News Claim of Methodist/Islamist Convergence

The websites of New York anti-Islam crusader Pamela Geller and radio conspiracist Alex Jones are claiming an obscure United Methodist congregation in Waco, Texas is part of a plan to Islamicize Methodist churches.

According to

On-the-ground sources in west Texas confirm that the United Methodist Church (UMC) is potentially engaged in a massive operation designed to reprogram churches as virtual mosques in preparation for a deluge of Muslim refugees.

The article quotes at length an anonymous reported church member who, “fearing for his safety,” told that Bosqueville United Methodist Church (UMC) in Waco might offer “Catholic-style ‘sanctuary’ protections for Muslim refugees, including possible terrorists (ISIS, al Qaeda, etc.).”

According to the supposed anonymous source, an interim pastor for weeks was “inundating the congregation with watered down, Islamized scripture,” after which the church was asked to host Muslim refugees, which the church supposedly rejected. Ominously, also “learned that the church installed state-of-the-art video surveillance systems” whose “content is viewed off-site at an undisclosed location; even the church staff supposedly do not know where the content can be viewed.”

The article claims churches are increasingly “getting visits from ‘clergy’ urging them to virtually roll over and accept an Islamic future.” It suggests United Methodism might receive Muslim refugees and cosequent Islamicization because of the “typically hyper-partisan composition of its congregations,” an odd assertion to anyone familiar with the denomination. Additionally, it says, “there’s also evidence that suggests Hillary Clinton may be behind UMC’s new Islamic flavor,” since the Washington, DC church she attended 1993-2001 now partners with a Muslim group.

In a further flight from reality, the article claims, as an illustration of the threat, that “10,000 churches in the UK alone were volunteered to be used as mosques to accommodate the influx of assimilation-resistant Muslims.” It links to another article that makes no such claim but that instead reports the closure of 10,000 British churches in recent decades.

The articles concludes melodramatically:

From Kool-Aid drinking gone wrong, to today’s unholy union of government, churches, and Islamic invaders, Waco is yet again ground zero for a suicidal event – but this time, every life in the country may be at stake.

Not to be outdone, but apparently based exclusively upon without bothering to seek additional sourcing, Alex Jones’ website breathlessly claimed:

The United Methodist Church is reportedly implementing a statewide plan to revamp Texas churches into “virtual mosques” catering to incoming Muslim migrants. The UMC, which has been criticized for perceived liberal drift in its theology, is preparing its congregations for Catholic-style “sanctuary” protections for migrants, including those with terrorist ties, according to an insider. reiterated that’s supposed anonymous source said “he learned about the ‘virtual mosque’ program after an interim pastor began preaching Sufi Islamic parables in an attempt to ‘tenderize’ the church to accept Islamification.”

The Drudge Report linked to the account and tweeted it to its one million followers.

Meanwhile a Waco local TV station investigated the story and found no evidence to support the colorful claims that a Waco church was potentially a tool for Islamicizing churches. “You can’t believe everything that you read,” the church’s new pastor is quoted in response. “I’ve just never heard anything like that before.” An elderly church member who says he hasn’t missed church in five years reports never hearing any sermon like what claimed.

Bosqueville United Methodist Church as of 2015 had only 49 members and an average attendance of 33, with likely minimal financial resources, probably making it an unlikely target for refugee resettlement much less an effective tool for Islamization.

So was the histrionic report based on at least a factual fragment? Maybe the interim minister suggested openness to Mideast refugees and one listener exaggerated the message. Or did’s writer fabricate the entire story by referencing an imaginary anonymous source, while assuming a tiny church had little capacity for response?

Do false news outlets even care if rebutted? Doubtless many tens of thousands will gobble up the silly claims from and without ever hearing any rebuttal.

Recently on Facebook I noticed a former beloved pastor of mine, now retired and in his 80s, pleading for his Facebook friends to help him understand which reports were reliable and which were not. He referenced a particular false news story that apparently originated in Eastern Europe but was widely circulated in the USA. This retired pastor was confused, because after all, many of his friends had posted this story. So it must be valid, right?

As someone who for many years has tried to report accurately about United Methodism, and often very critically from a conservative/orthodox perspective regarding our denomination’s controversies, I am troubled that false news is no longer so abstract but has now afflicted my own church, which has enough real problems without fabricated ones.

Christians on social media are especially vulnerable to false news inroads. I hope more will try to be more skeptical and discerning.

5 Responses to False News Claim of Methodist/Islamist Convergence

  1. Timothy Earl says:

    Other than a mention that a waco news station did an article (no links provided) your article is just as fake. No facts, finger throwing and simply shamful writing. I think the story on the UMC is fake to, but you’re right with them.

    • Joseph Rossell says:

      That’s not true. Look again. The local TV report was linked to the whole time. The pastor goes on camera and uses his real name, plus the reporter quotes the statement from annual conference.

  2. Prentice Durwood Worley says:

    I have confidence in the news reporting of Mark Tooley. However, I know for a fact that a church in the Memphis Conference has bonded with a Muslin congregation. Here is a recent post of the Memphis Conference news: Heartsong United Methodist Church and the Memphis Islamic Center, neighbors in Cordova, Tennessee, will celebrate Thanksgiving together on Thursday, Nov. 17, at 6:30 pm at Heartsong.

  3. Dan says:

    I’ll admit that conspiracy theories abound, but this Infowars article caught my attention because of what I personally experienced in the Va Annual Conference just over 10 years ago. On the Sunday nearest 9/11, our guest preacher used her sermon to lecture us on the requirement to love our enemies and then proceeded to call out “God bless Usama Bin Laden.” A few months later at our staff/parish relations meeting, we were discussing ecumenical relations and I stated that, in my position as committee chair, I could not condone having a Muslim imam participate in one of our services. One of the committee members then said – “Why not, Muslims worship the same God that we do.” After waiting several moments for our pastor to correct this, which was not forthcoming, I had to remind her that we assuredly do not worship the same God and then explain why not. I guess our pastor disagreed although she later opined that those Christians who believer in the inerrancy of the Bible are guilty of idolatry because they are making the Bible their God.

    Until UMC seminaries are purged of education that produces pastors who do not believe the Bible or the ancient creeds, and espouse a syncretistic religion that sees Jesus as one possible way while the national UMC encourages people to “follow your own path,” the national UMC will be in continuing danger from such pastors and unaccountable bishops and jurisdictions. While the particulars of what happened and is happening at Bosqueville UMC may be in dispute, I find it entirely believable given what is happening in the UMC these days, and what I have personally experienced during the time I was a member in the Va Annual Conference.

  4. Joseph E. says:

    I am 93 yrs old and have been a Methodist member all my life, even as it was leaning more and more to the left as they embraced same sex marriage, gays in the pulpit and now bonding with Muslims. I no longer can tolerate the unbiblical stand. I can read the Bible and understand what God has said. I don’t believe He applauded any of these sinful acts
    and I shall be on His side come what may. Justification, in the Bible itself.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *