Anglican decline

Anglican Decline, Pandemic and Pandemonium in “Challenging Times”

on June 26, 2020

Anglicans have had a rough year, according to Archbishop Foley Beach in in a somber but hopeful address before the Anglican Church in North America (ACNA) Provincial Council, meeting June 23-24 in an online web conference.

Beach cited tired clergy facing “decision fatigue” amidst the COVID-19 pandemic, violence and racial injustice, and the departure of two dioceses last year leading to the denomination’s first significant drop in numbers.

There was also positive news: favorable decisions were handed down for the Dioceses of Fort Worth and South Carolina in long-running legal conflicts with the Episcopal Church from which they had disaffiliated.

“God has been using our churches in big ways not only with online ministries, but caring for the needy and those in hard times,” Beach noted.

“A Sin Problem”

Much of Beach’s address focused upon racial strife.

“The past few months have not only been pandemic, but pandemonium,” the Anglican archbishop summarized, referencing “evil displayed by fellow image bearers and some police officers in recent weeks.”

Beach referenced hearing louder “cries of grief in our own neighborhoods” and peaceful protests “hijacked by chaos and violence” destroying property, injuring both bystanders and more than 800 police officers.

Bishop John Guernsey, Dean of Provincial Affairs, has been tasked by the College of Bishops to put together a Working Group on Race, Racism, and Racial Reconciliation “to help us talk as Biblical Christians in the midst of a polarized culture.”

“We have failed to fully and thoroughly and deeply address the problem of sin in our hearts, homes, churches, and nations,” Beach diagnosed. Racism, “in its root, it is a sin problem. We need God to rend our hearts as a Church.”

The Archbishop said the Church must acknowledge “systemic sins” but also distance from “those movements that are promoting anarchy, destruction of the family, and the dismantling of our government.”

“It will not be through political parties, rallies, slogans or marches that our attitudes and practices are changed, that the souls of our nations are converted,” Beach stated.

The “revival that comes from repentance” starts “in your own relationship with God,” and then in “building a relationship with someone different than you are,” he said

Anglican Decline?

The ACNA saw decline across three objective measures in 2019: membership, attendance, and number of churches. Most of the decline, which staff said “should not necessarily raise alarm,” is attributed to the withdrawal of two dioceses in the Convocation of Anglicans in North America: West and Trinity.

Three CANA dioceses operated within both ACNA and the Church of Nigeria. In 2019, an agreement prompted these dioceses to continue with a single province. CANA East continued as part of ACNA and changed its name to Diocese of the Living Word. CANA West and Trinity (largely composed of expatriate Nigerians) opted to continue as part of the Church of Nigeria. The dioceses remain relationally connected to ACNA through the Global Anglican Future Conference (GAFCON) but their bishops are no longer seated in the ACNA College of Bishops and their clergy are no longer canonically resident in ACNA.

Archbishop Beach did not sugarcoat the loss to the Council: “We felt the sting of division. We have watched some broken relationships go unhealed.”

The number of ACNA congregations decreased by a net of 94, from 1,066 to 972. Membership decreased from 133,279 in 2018 to 127,624 in 2019, attendance declined from 87,319 to 84,310.

Adjusting for the two CANA departures, the Province, while still declining in number of congregations (-20), grew slightly in membership (+202) and attendance (+559).

The reported numbers represent the first significant decline in the denomination, which emphasized church plants and adding first-time Anglicans, since it was formed in 2009.

Dioceses reporting significant attendance gains in 2019 included Churches for the Sake of Others (+419), South Carolina (+670), Rocky Mountains (+591) and the Anglican Network in Canada (+319). Declines were reported in the Dioceses of Christ Our Hope (-384), Quincy (-245), Western Gulf Coast (-246), and Fort Worth (-267). A complete chart can be viewed below. (Note that some declines and gains may be partly attributed to transfer of congregations between dioceses.)

ACNA Statistics

Provincial Council includes an elected four-person delegation from each ACNA diocese: bishop, clergy, and two lay delegates. It convenes annually and oversees governance between gatherings of Provincial Assembly, a larger body with representation based on diocesan size.

The Council elected to the denomination’s Executive Committee Albert Thompson of the Diocese of the Mid-Atlantic and Deborah Tepley of the Anglican Diocese of Christ Our Hope in the lay order and Herb Bailey from the Diocese of Pittsburgh and Chris Culpepper of the Diocese of Fort Worth in the clergy order. They will serve three-year terms.

Watch Archbishop Beach’s address to Provincial Council, delivered via a Zoom web conference, below:

  1. Comment by Nick on June 26, 2020 at 3:57 pm

    Typos corrected

    Politically, I doubt it will ever happen but it seems like the ACNA has way too many dioceses for such a small church. Also dioceses seem to be built around personalities of clergy and dynamics of intra-church politics from 10 years ago.

  2. Comment by David on June 27, 2020 at 8:21 am

    Churches of the Anglican tradition in the US have demographics not unlike that of the UMC. The membership is heavy at the older end of the age scale and lighter on the younger end, the median age being about 57. The US population has a median age of about 46. Nearly a third are over 65 compared to 18% of the US and about 8% are age 18 to 29 compared to 22% of the US population. The memberships of these churches are obviously aging out.

  3. Comment by Jeffrey Walton on June 29, 2020 at 9:30 am

    Yes, these are relevant stats, David. I think the key things that distinguish ACNA from the Episcopal Church from a demographic perspective is 1) ACNA seems to have a larger percentage of immigrants. 2) ACNA is drawing a significant number of people from Evangelical backgrounds, including clergy. 3) I see many more children in ACNA parishes than I do in TEC ones, and we can document this because of the relatively large number of baptisms (there are many three-and-four child families at my church, I encounter few of those in this generation in TEC).

    All that being said, former Episcopalians in ACNA are demographically near-identical to current Episcopalians: white, lower rates of reproduction / later marriage, rapidly aging. My ACNA diocese is mostly led by former Episcopalians influenced by the charismatic revival, and we have a visible divide between churches that began in TEC and those that were planted after the separation (the latter are far younger and more likely to be growing).

  4. Comment by Gene Vajgrt on June 27, 2020 at 11:43 am

    This is an afront to me! I object to being called racist by a man that I don’t know (Lebhar) and (Beach) and who I don’t want to know. The tone of this missive is not only disgusting in it’s entirety but should be deleted and an apology issued to all members of the church. PLEASE ensure that I don’t get any more of Lebhar and/or Beach personal political views.

  5. Comment by Jeffrey Walton on June 27, 2020 at 5:08 pm

    Lebhar isn’t quoted or mentioned in the article. Beach hasn’t called me or you racist: he’s asked for people to engage in personal self-examination and repentance. The reading of scripture and the preaching of the Gospel will, with the prompting of the Holy Spirit, direct each of us to the areas of our lives that need restoration. That’s not an expressly political call, although it may result in change within our lives and the lives of those around us.

  6. Comment by Joan Oliver on June 29, 2020 at 7:00 pm

    Who is Lebhar?

  7. Comment by Jeffrey Walton on June 30, 2020 at 9:26 am

    He might be referring to Bishop Neil Lebhar, who leads the ACNA’s Gulf-Atlantic Diocese. Since Lebhar is unmentioned in my report, I assume he was earlier mentioned in something else that linked to my blog entry.

  8. Comment by Evan Baker on June 30, 2020 at 10:51 am

    There seem to be something off with the the 2018 Western Anglican membership number (too high) resulting in a “drop” when the 2019 number is reported. Similarly, the Anglican Network in Canada 2018 membership number is too low, resulting in an increase when the correct 2019 number is reported (and the 2017 ANiC attendance number is a glaring error). That being said, the differences between the Western Anglican and ANiC numbers look to almost balance each other out.

The work of IRD is made possible by your generous contributions.

Receive expert analysis in your inbox.