military theocracy

Military Theocracy?

on January 14, 2020

Apparently theocracy is being launched through the U.S. military by the Episcopal Church.

A small but aggressive secular group that peddles theocracy conspiracy theories is getting media attention for complaining about blessing a military Bible. According to an NPR headline, the ceremony sparked “outrage.”

The public “outrage” seemingly was mostly confined to several irritable tweets.

The liberal Washington National Cathedral hosted a pro forma Bible blessing for the new U.S. Space Command, attended by the U.S. Air Force chief of chaplains. Officiating was the Episcopal Church’s Bishop to the Armed Forces and Federal Ministries Carl Wright.

This Bible will be used to swear in future officers of the U.S. Space Command, if they so choose.

The complainant against the Bible blessing was Mikey Weinstein, of the Military Religious Freedom Foundation, which through media advocacy and litigation condemns military chaplaincies and imagines the military is a hotbed of “Christian privilege.”

“The MRFF condemns, in as full-throated a manner as is humanly possible, the shocking and repulsive display of only the most vile, exclusivist, fundamentalist Christian supremacy, dominance, triumphalism and exceptionalism which occurred at yesterday’s ‘blessing’ at the Washington National Cathedral,” Weinstein complained.

Anyone who’s familiar with National Cathedral can only laugh at Weinstein’s faux outrage. The cathedral belongs to the Episcopal Church and, in contrast to “fundamentalist Christianity supremacy,” is home to refined Mainline Protestant liberalism and political correctness.

The Episcopal Church and the Washington National Cathedral, because of their history as pastorate to America’s political and cultural elites, do often officiate in rites of American civil religion. Although small and declining, the Episcopal Church continues to play an outsized role in military chaplaincy.

In recent years the Episcopal Church is better known for LGBTQ advocacy and climate change activism than for robust Christian orthodoxy, much less “fundamentalism.” Oblivious or indifferent to that reality, Weinstein warned:

“If MRFF’s fervent attempts to exhaust all DoD administrative remedies to eliminate this fundamentalist Christian tyranny and oppression fail, MRFF will plan to stop this matter in Federal court in Northern Virginia. The utilization of a Christian Bible to ‘swear in’ commanders of the new Space Force or any other DoD branch at ANY level is completely violative of the bedrock separation of church and state mandate of the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.”

Of course, military commanders are sworn in on whatever book they choose, or no book at all. There is no compulsion, just as military chaplains of various religions can’t and don’t compel any service member to participate in any religious rites. And the chaplaincy doesn’t promote Christian “supremacy.” Recently the U.S. Army commissioned its first female Muslim candidate for chaplaincy. The chaplaincy represents America’s religious diversity, and it also reflects that most Americans identify as Christian.

Secularist fanatics like Weinstein believe religion should be effectively banished from public life. But humans are intrinsically spiritual. Every nation and community will have spirituality, just as each person has soul and spirit. America affirms religious freedom. America does not restrict religion to closets and basements. Religion is not strictly private or personal. It is communal and public.

For all their contemporary faddishness and occasional silliness, the Episcopal Church and the Washington National Cathedral serve important roles in mediating public religiosity in America, inimitably deploying the stately tools and arenas of their tradition. Authentic “fundamentalists” can offer nothing similar.

Weinstein called the brief National Cathedral Bible blessing a “constitutional horror.” But it was just the opposite, illustrating that religious institutions and religious voices are protected by the Constitution, which is essential to liberty for all people.

  1. Comment by JR on January 14, 2020 at 10:43 am

    Must be a slow news day.

  2. Comment by Palamas on January 14, 2020 at 11:54 am

    Weinstein is a Soviet-style atheist, who would not only ban public displays of religion, but ban religion, if he could. He can bang his spoon on his high chair all he wants, but the First Amendment is going to be repealed any time soon.

  3. Comment by David on January 14, 2020 at 3:42 pm

    Federal oaths do not require a Bible and several Presidents have taken their oaths on bound copies of the Constitution. Oaths themselves are not even required and an affirmation can be taken instead. States often have similar rules though I can imagine a part of the country where this would not apply. The military is not a shining light of religious freedom. Academy cadets were required to attend religious services until not so long ago. At the Air Force Academy, those who chose not to attend had to march out in a sort of humiliation parade. Of course, the scandal over fundamentalist influence there is not forgotten. The need to promote “God is on our side” is historically found in many militaries.

  4. Comment by Daryl Densford on January 15, 2020 at 1:53 am

    Weinstein should just be sidelined from public discourse, along with his ridiculous claims…except for his Constitutional rights which he seems to want to deny others!

    And a small correction, it was the Air Force, not the Army, who just commissioned their first female Chaplain Candidate.

  5. Comment by Lawrence Hall on January 16, 2020 at 3:50 pm

    We have no national cathedral because we have no national religion. That is the Episcopal Cathedral Church of St. Peter and St. Paul.

  6. Comment by jonathan on January 17, 2020 at 9:13 pm

    Most of those complaining clowns would be perfect for the Space Force anyway as they have so much of it already between their ears…. Praise God, and pass the prayer support for President Trump!

  7. Comment by David Soo on January 17, 2020 at 10:17 pm

    Good post! -a 23 y/o conservative christian

  8. Comment by Fr. JD Sims on January 18, 2020 at 9:19 am

    TO THE AUTHOR: You have stated recently that the Army has appointed a female Muslim Chaplain. I believe you may have meant to say Air Force not Army Chaplaincy has appointed a female Muslim Chaplain. Thanks for the informative article!

  9. Comment by Jeffrey Gorman on January 19, 2020 at 3:54 pm

    Many of us conservative Episcopalians( I know there are still some of us who have not moved to ACNA) realize that National Cathedral is the NATIONALCATHEDRAL of the Nation which just happens to be controlled by Liberal Folks who are certainly anything but Fundamentalists. This is a tempest in a very small teapot.

The work of IRD is made possible by your generous contributions.

Receive expert analysis in your inbox.