archbishop welby

Archbishop of Canterbury: Insisting on Exclusive Truth is Arrogant, Narrow

on September 26, 2018

This past Sunday, the Archbishop of Canterbury, the Most Reverend and Right Honorable Justin Welby, visited Trinity Wall Street, an Episcopal church founded in 1697 that is located just one block from the New York Stock Exchange.

The Archbishop encouraged his hearers to be persons of wisdom. How? Surprisingly, he did not turn to Proverbs 9:10, which says “The fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom.” Instead, he cited Psalm 1 to say that the search for heavenly wisdom “begins with our identity,” and this identity can only be found when we are outward-looking.

“Praise God for Trinity’s outward-lookness,” he said. In 2013, the New York Times reported that Trinity owned assets totaling $2 billion, including “5.5 million square feet of commercial real estate.” The same article added:

“The parish’s good fortune has become an issue in the historic congregation, which has been racked by infighting in recent years over whether the church should be spending more money to help the poor and spread the faith, in New York and around the world. Differences over the parish’s mission and direction last year led nearly half the 22-member vestry — an august collection of corporate executives and philanthropists — to resign or be pushed out, after at least seven of them asked, unsuccessfully, that the rector himself step down.”

Archbishop Welby limited his remarks to only 20 minutes so that the corporate executives and philanthropists could devote themselves again to that outward-looking mindset. However, he did take time to provide some helpful advice about what was certain and uncertain.

“We know for certain that climate change is a reality that will utterly change the lives of billions,” he said. However, “even the best minds don’t know what is going to happen in the future” (except for climate change, of course).

In the same vein, he expressed uncertainty about Christians’ hope in an “inheritance that is imperishable, undefiled, and unfading, kept in heaven for you” (see 1 Peter 1:4). Invoking John Bunyan’s classic allegory, The Pilgrim’s Progress, he noted that “the celestial city of our great dreams is far away.” He added, “nor perhaps do we find in the end that it was the right vision, and the real goal.”

The Archbishop also displayed his talent as a master of comedy. According to their church calendar, the Episcopal Church Old Testament reading for September 23, 2018 came from Proverbs 31:10-31, which beautifully idealizes the Biblical view of womanhood (for starters, she is wife, mother, business manager, and international merchant). Welby used the opportunity to lighten the mood with this exchange:

“By the way, I am not going to deal with the reading from the Proverbs.” (Audience laughter) “I hear you thinking: ‘you coward’”—and, after a pause—“yes.” (More laughter) “He who fights and runs away lives to fight another day. I’m not even going to comment on why I’m not going to comment on that reading.” (Laughter again) “I know an elephant trap when I see one.”

Apparently some portions of Scripture are more controversial than climate change.

But perhaps Archbishop Welby was merely trying to be wise. After all, he said, Christian wisdom consists not in being “survivalists” or “triumphalists,” but peacemakers. He admitted that sometimes “to avoid looking too unchristian, we apply some camouflage paint to our motives to reshape them a little.”

Strikingly, the symbolic head of the worldwide Anglican Communion criticized anyone who insisted on possessing an exclusive truth. “To some, the preaching of their own wisdom being the only one, their own view being the only one, is overt, proclaimed, and that becomes sectarianism.” This insistence on homogeneity, said the Archbishop, ignores cultural diversity, and is therefore culturally imperialistic and profoundly arrogant. “When we are that narrow, we quench the Spirit,” he warned.

It is unclear whether Archbishop Welby would back away from the exclusiveness of statements like “If anyone is preaching to you a gospel contrary to the one you received, let him be accursed” (Galatians 1:9), and “No one comes to the Father except through me” (John 14:6). He might also be uncomfortable with the preaching of John Bunyan, which Bunyan himself admitted was characterized by “crying out against men’s sins and their fearful state because of them.”

Nevertheless, the Archbishop did encourage his audience to imitate the child from Matthew 18:1-4. He said Jesus used this child to rebuke his disciples for their narcissistic ambition “by calling them to dependence on God alone.” The way of Christian wisdom is in simplicity and peace, he said.

  1. Comment by Stuart Sherman on September 26, 2018 at 10:45 am

    Assets of TWO BILLION dollars!! So how much is listed on their balance sheet for outreach or evangelism?

  2. Comment by David on September 26, 2018 at 4:57 pm

    Trinity Church has been one of the largest landowners in NYC since a royal charter in 1697. The poor conditions in tenements owned by them was exposed by the NYT in the 1890s. Trinity Church also has the right to any whale that washes up on the shores of Manhattan.

  3. Comment by Dan W on September 27, 2018 at 7:01 pm

    “At that time many will turn away from the faith and will betray and hate each other, and many false prophets will appear and deceive many people.” Matthew 24:10-11 NIV

  4. Comment by George H Ivey on September 28, 2018 at 4:34 pm

    What a heart break. Welby has crucified the Lord of Glory all over again! What a minimization of wisdom of God in Christ Jesus! Because of Welby’s origins with Holy Trinity Brompton, I had high hopes that he would hold the unique Incarnate Word high so that He would draw all people to Himself. What a disappointment. He has taken the easy way that leads downward. Welby’s view totally ignores the fruit of the apostolic Gospel and betrays the blood of the martyrs and especially Cranmer’s, Ridley’s, Latimer’s and Bradford’s.
    Welby blew his eternal opportunity to bring the Episcopal church back to its roots. What a shame!

  5. Comment by The Rev.Dr. Samuel E. Pinzon on September 28, 2018 at 8:15 pm

    The way of Christian wisdom is: sacrifice, service, selflessness and humility and being aware and certain that preaching a gospel contrary to the one given by Jesus Christ as it is found in the Christian Bible will be a cause to be accursed.

  6. Comment by Qaz on September 28, 2018 at 9:45 pm

    So many words, so little substance.

  7. Comment by Judy B on October 5, 2018 at 2:46 pm

    We Anglicans here, in South Carolina are preparing to hand over 29 churches to the Episcopal Church because we stand with the authority of Scripture and the Trinity. These churches will have to hand over the keys, lock stock and barrel and all the assests that go with them because we are faithful to the faith. That’s about $500 million in properties! How sad…and they won’t have enough priests or staff to take them over so they of course will sell them. Some of these churches in SC were built in 1761 and even some before. They call us “breakaway” churches but we say…”who moved”?

  8. Comment by Marianne Aiken on October 5, 2018 at 5:02 pm

    God bless you Anglicans and prosper you for your courage and faith. What a needless tragedy for South Carolina!

The work of IRD is made possible by your generous contributions.

Receive expert analysis in your inbox.

 ⛪ Will you choose IRD this Giving Tuesday?

The Religious Left has fought hard this year to continue its deconstruction of traditional Christianity and its hostility to America — but IRD has fought harder. Some on the right have despaired and want to give up on American democracy — but supporters like you know there is always hope. Many great Protestant denominations have often forgotten or even rejected the best of their traditions — but thousands of congregations have remained faithful. Unlike the demagogues on the left, IRD is lifting up these Protestant traditions, hosting and spotlighting scholars and resources that give us tools and hope for the future! So today we ask you to make a gesture of hope by donating to IRD's Giving Tuesday campaign in the amount that's right for you.

Donate here