The responses to the white supremacy rally and the resulting violence in Charlottesville have metastasized out of proportion to what happened. The media’s amplification and exploitation of last weekend’s events, the surrounding tensions and virtue signaling reactions have been irresponsible and destructive. The renewed push to erase history by removing Confederate memorabilia from public view are misguided acts – superficial symbolism that won’t have a meaningful effect in reducing white identity politics or racial discrimination.
What’s also been irresponsible are some of the responses and reactions by Christian onlookers.
To achieve and maintain a credible, public Christian political witness, truth must be valued. So must humility, temperance, consistency, brotherly kindness, and other qualities that are perfectly reflective of what it means to be Christian and to uphold Christian character.
Sadly, much of that seems to be lacking from many Christian responses. Rather than responding in a manner morally reflective of the Sermon on the Mount, many of these reactions are merely self-serving sermons on soapboxes that serve and misplace blame or are steeped in racial moral grandstanding.
For example, several written reactions and responses from black Christians have been as foolish as they are discouraging. These “Christian” reactions have amounted to scolding white Christians and pastors for contributing to white supremacy (and by extension, the racists in Charlottesville) and demanding apologies for their contributions to it. After berating alleged Christian sympathizers of white supremacy, these black Christians suggest that their fellow white brothers and sisters in Christ sit down, shut up and obediently listen to embellished, politicized accounts of racial victimization cloaked in a Christian veneer. They then oblige white Christians to clean up the racial mess white Christians created with the possibility of earning a few racial penance points for challenging the guilt and sin of white supremacy.
It’s certainly self-serving and beneficial for any black Christians that support this program of coerced repentance. But this doesn’t solve the extremes of Charlottesville (which isn’t related to Christianity) or soothe interracial (or interethnic) tensions and inequalities in the American Church.
And it’s certainly not Christian.
I’ve also seen white Christians engage in hyper-remorseful apologies, pressuring white Christians, in effect, to hyperbolize their apologies and forcefully address the issue in a way they otherwise wouldn’t. In this mindset, not doing so augments the racial sin because silence somehow makes the silent complicit in the racialized evil of white supremacy. These responses amount to proactive shows of racial deference, and frankly they come across as insincere attempts at remorse that are more reflective of racial humiliation than Christian humility.
Believe me – I’m not discounting the very real presence and evil of racism, particularly in the form of white supremacy. I’m also not suggesting that Christians, regardless of color, sit back and be apprehensive or refuse to address racial (ethnic) issues from a deeply theological perspective. Frankly the American Church hasn’t engaged this theological task seriously, repentantly, or consistently enough.
But I am saying the responses fall quite short of what they could and should be.
For example, in addition to condemning race hatred and evil, what we Christians should be calling for is the same Christian response that followed in the aftermath of the Emanuel A.M.E. Church shooting in Charleston, South Carolina, back in June 2015. Dylann Roof, a loner and a white supremacist sympathizer, felt racially marginalized and wanted to start a race war so he murdered nine innocent people at Bible study.
During Roof’s bond hearing, family members and loved ones of those murdered by Roof had an opportunity to confront him. In such a situation, a multitude of emotions – shock, anger, and grief – are naturally understandable and expected from those mourning the loss of loved ones taken in such a horrific and evil manner. Though sad, shocked, and grieving, the victimized families held little anger, in spite of the evil that took their loved ones. Family members and members of the Charleston community came together with folk who traveled across the country to Charleston in love, prayer, and forgiveness.
One by one, those still mired in shock and grief offered Dylann Roof forgiveness and told him that they were praying for his soul, even as they described the intense suffering and pain from their losses.
Nadine Collier, whose 70-year-old mother, Ethel Lance, was one of nine victims, said, “I forgive you. You took something very precious from me. I will never talk to her again. I will never, ever hold her again. But I forgive you. And have mercy on your soul.”
Felicia Sanders, who lost her 26-year-old son, Tywanza Sanders, said tearfully, “We welcomed you Wednesday night in our Bible study with welcome arms. Tywanza Sanders was my son. But Tywanza Sanders was my hero. Tywanza was my hero…. May God have mercy on you.”
The sister of the Reverend DePayne Middleton-Doctor admitted, “I acknowledge that I am very angry. But one thing that DePayne always enjoined in our family . . . is she taught me that we are the family that love built. We have no room for hating, so we have to forgive. I pray God [has mercy] on your soul.”
Camryn and Chris Singleton, whose 45-year-old mother, Reverend Sharonda Coleman-Singleton, also died, somberly offered forgiveness. Chris said of Roof, “We already forgive him for what he’s done, and there’s nothing but love from our side of the family.” His sister Camryn added, “I just feel a lot of love. I’m a little bitter, but I’m overwhelmed with love.” Reverend Norvell Goff, the then-interim pastor of Emanuel A.M.E. Church, echoed the same things—love, prayer, and forgiveness.
There was no virtue signaling, no racial condescension, and no humiliating self-interested gestures masked as apologies. It was a response mired in pain but tempered by love and forgiveness that overcame white supremacy and hatred, and this response shocked the country.
This is the quality of response Christians should be calling for.
Comment by John Kenyon on August 18, 2017 at 1:49 pm
Appreciate you comments, Derryck Green. Thanks,
Comment by Larry on August 19, 2017 at 8:56 am
One of the few theologians who understand what it is to be Christ like. Thanks Mr. Green.
Comment by Nancy Carson Gray on August 19, 2017 at 12:16 pm
There are just no words to describe how dark the human heart really is or how amazing the transforming love and grace of Christ Jesus can be for those who embrace Him in total surrender. Former slave trader, John Newton writes about his miraculous transformation, “Amazing grace how sweet the sound that saved a wretch like me.” Praise God! I pray healing, encouragement, and God’s comforting presence for those beautiful Christians at the AME Church in Charleston. That’s what we as Christians should be about. Jesus wipe every tear from their eyes.
Comment by Adrian Keister on August 22, 2017 at 8:49 am
Thank you, sir, for your Christ-like words, for pointing people to the gospel – the only thing that can solve the problem of racism. For it is in the gospel that we find out how universally bad we all are, regardless of skin color, and how great is God’s grace to his people, regardless of skin color. There’s no room for any superiority at the bottom!
Comment by Anne Stein on August 22, 2017 at 9:57 pm
I really appreciate your sentiments, but think that there is a difference between people who suffered losses forgiving and others demanding forgiveness, or “forced repentance” by others. There is still plenty of assumption of white superiority (or anti-semitism) that sneaks into the hearts of any of us that we all need to root out. I pray that the Lord shows me any remnants that I have have not yet discovered and clean me of such sin.
Comment by Jan Welch on August 23, 2017 at 11:25 am
We all need to remember that God created us all, everyone, and after he finished creation He said “It is good.” We are all God’s people and we need to treat each other with respect and consideration. It seems so often that we are in separate camps and so suspicious of each other having lost the ability to trust. Everyone needs to take a deep breath, forgive our own and others sins and look at each other as brothers and sisters in Christ. God help us all
Comment by Jim Kinkade on August 30, 2017 at 10:21 am
Ok. How should Christians confront hatred against white people? Should Christians speak out against Jewish supremacy? It’s probably something we should talk about before our civilization collapses because of white genocide.
Comment by Inwoo Lee on February 2, 2021 at 1:18 am
Very thoughtful piece, especially the conclusion.