September 16, 2012

Young Evangelicals and Politics

How will and should young evangelicals approach politics in this election year and beyond? Four distinguished young evangelicals offered guidance at a panel at this year’s Value Voters Summit, hosted by the Family Research Council and other pro-family groups this weekend in Washington, DC.


Called “Millennials and the Future of Political Engagement,” and moderated by FRC Social Media Manager Chris Marlink, the panelists argued against apathy or shifting left, trends evinced among some young evangelicals in recent years.

“There are abundant examples of Christians throughout history who’ve achieved political victories,” explained Owen Strachan, Professor of Christian Theology and Church History at Boyce College in Louisville, Kentucky. He cited movements for temperance, abolition, and public health in the 19th century, plus anti lynching and civil rights campaigns in the 20th. Christian political reformers knew they were “first citizens of the kingdom of God” but weren’t “exempt from meaningful involvement in the kingdom of man.”

Strachan warned: “We’re at something like the zero hour with gay marriage.” Political uninvolvement is only helping America choose gay marriage, he regretted. “America is not the new Jerusalem,” Strachan said. “But we need to vote.” And he challenged Christians: “You have to fundamentally redefine history,” noting, “We have the ultimate… life changing transformative message.”

Echoing Strachan, Family Foundation Policy Analyst Andrew Walker of Louisville, Kentucky, noted that Jesus and His apostles “reordered political allegiances” by teaching Caesar’s subordination to God. Walker warned against “moral equivalency” that fails to distinguish between “building wells or opposing abortion.”

Walker stressed that when “Christian ethics confront the public square,” asserting opinions about how the world ought to be governed, partisanship becomes inevitable. He rued the “ideal of non partisanship” currently in vogue among some evangelicals. “It’s not what democracy is built on,” he said. “Democracy depends on persuading people.”

Stressing God’s pre-existing victory through Christ, Walker said, “Our job is to give witness to what has been decisively accomplished,” but also to “season with salt and grace.” He admitted that speaking gently to hostile media like Pierce Morgan won’t reduce resistance.

Citing such hostility and threats to religious freedom, likes Obamacare’s contraceptive/abortifacient mandate on religious groups, Eric Teetsel of the Manhattan Declaration foresaw the “next level” of threats. “People in this room may end up in prison in my lifetime, maybe sooner,” he speculated of Christians who “won’t render up to Caesar what belongs to God.”

Many “young evangelicals don’t want to pay the cost of [losing] cultural cache,” Teetsel observed. But he also celebrated ongoing widespread resistance to cultural elitists such as support for Chik-fil-A.

After Teetsel, author Matthew Lee Anderson defended the political importance of abortion and marriage, which he called “symbols of our concern for life.” But he noted Christians have not always been “on our a game when it comes to messaging.” He encouraged “a tone that is…cheerful and winsome,” amid an “unfair media environment” where “one error is magnified” and there’s “no room for mistakes.”

Anderson urged “more craftiness in our presentation” and more attention to branding. He admitted culture war may not be good for the social order but is unsure it’s avoidable right now. He urged appeals for mercy amid hostility. “I’m not sure this thing gets solved without Jesus,” Anderson concluded.

10 Responses to Young Evangelicals and Politics

  1. pat samson says:

    The problem with evangelicals now is that their only focus is abortion and limiting gay people’s rights (even if Jesus never condemned homosexuality) no wonder the young aren’t interested in their message. The more comprehensive and socially just focus of the 19th and early 20th century evangelicals who fought against slavery and for women’s rights and more has been lost to a modern and a bizarre fundamentalism that has taken over most evanagelical churches.

    • Donnie says:

      I don’t understand how any Christian can support abortion. 55 million babies murdered in cold blood since 1973… Forget about being Christian, how can anybody with a single shred of human decency support that!?

  2. cynthia curran says:

    Well, Christians have opposed Homosexuality in the common law of England and the Justinian Code, its only in modern times that the penalties have been lifted. Granted, i don’t favor jailing gays again but gay marriage should not be made legal. And I’am a conservative more because of foreign policy and economics than the social issues.

  3. joseph sanchez says:

    Jesus never condemned homosexuality? You don’t think it’s covered in condemnations of adultery and fornication?? That’s crazy.

  4. […] He is a native of Virginia and a life-long Methodist.¬† This article first appear at the IRD blog and is used with […]

  5. […] Young Evangelicals and Politics Mark Tooley, Juicy Ecumnism How will and should young evangelicals approach politics in this election year and beyond? Leave a Reply Click here to cancel reply. Name Required: […]

  6. […] protecting conservative evangelical Christians rights’ to their anti-abortion principles, see his conversation on “Young Evangelicals And Politics”; he claims he wants freedom and tolerance for his side,, but at the same time, he is taking away […]

  7. […] How will and should young evangelicals approach politics in this election year and beyond?  […]

  8. […] Tooley of the Institute on Religion and Democracy posted a great article on the panel which sheds some additional […]

  9. […] ¬†Listen to the panel audio here.Mark Tooley of the Institute on Religion and Democracy posted a great article on the panel which sheds some additional light.Here’s hoping that this panel, and efforts like it, helps […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *